Which difficulty variant was right most often?We have tested the fixture planner's difficulty variants against how the season actually went, with FPL's own FDR alongside. Here you can see which one was most often right about easy and hard fixtures.
Which difficulty variant was right most often?We have tested the fixture planner's difficulty variants against how the season actually went, with FPL's own FDR alongside. Here you can see which one was most often right about easy and hard fixtures.
FPL's FDRtoo few matches · since gameweek 10easy 3 of 5 · hard 4 of 520 matches
Matchup's level thresholds were set from the 2026/27 season's matches up to gameweek 9, so its levels carry a little hindsight.
FPL's FDR has been recorded from gameweek 10. It is tested against the FDR FPL showed before each deadline, never against today's values.
Like-for-like comparison
No winner yet: too few matches
Here all four variants are tested on the same matches: only those where FPL's FDR was recorded before the deadline, gameweeks 10–10. That way FDR competes on equal terms with the others.
VariantHit rateEasy and hardMatchesStaircase
Matchuptoo few matcheseasy 6 of 10 · hard 7 of 720 matches
xGtoo few matcheseasy 6 of 10 · hard 9 of 1020 matches
FPL's FDRtoo few matcheseasy 3 of 5 · hard 4 of 520 matches
Tabletoo few matcheseasy 3 of 8 · hard 5 of 720 matches
How are the variants tested?
Each variant is judged on what it showed before the gameweek, using only matches that had already been played. No peeking at the answers.
For the data variants the calculation is the same as in the fixture planner with its default settings: the whole season, no split between home and away, and home advantage on.
FPL's FDR is tested only against the values we recorded before each deadline. A gameweek with no recorded value is not tested at all, never with today's FDR, since FPL changes it during the season.
FDR counts for a match only if it was recorded for the gameweek the match was played in, between those clubs, so a moved match counts under its new gameweek.
What is a hit?
In attack, an easy match is a hit if the club scored 2 goals or more. A hard match is a hit if it scored fewer.
In defence, an easy match is a hit if the club kept a clean sheet. A hard match is a hit if it conceded 2 or more.
Level 3 is neither easy nor hard, so it does not count.
Hit rate
The hit rate is the average of the share of hits on easy matches and on hard matches. That way a variant cannot win by calling more matches hard, because both sides weigh the same.
The staircase
The staircase shows the average goals scored or conceded at each level. A good variant gives an even staircase: the easier the level, the more goals for the club in attack and the fewer conceded in defence.
Noise and small samples
There is a lot of luck in football. When two variants are close we say that one leads, but narrowly, because the gap could just as well be luck.
A variant with fewer than 15 easy or fewer than 15 hard calls shows as “too few matches” and does not compete.
Early season ends after gameweek 15, late season is the rest. Home and away are from the side of the club being judged: Home is the matches the club played at home.
A variant that started late is shown, but it does not compete for the win in the main table, since it has not been tested on the same matches as the others.
Like-for-like comparison
FPL's FDR is recorded before each deadline, but not always for every gameweek. The like-for-like comparison therefore tests all four variants only on the matches where FDR was recorded, with the same rules for small samples, and no winner while FDR has too few calls. When FDR covers every gameweek, the main table and the like-for-like comparison are tested on the same matches.